In a decision certain to receive close scrutiny by those representing potential presidential candidates, the FEC has dismissed the allegations made by Stop Hillary PAC against the Super PAC Ready for Hillary, Friends of Hillary and Senator Clinton herself. FEC MUR 6775. The FEC concluded in one part of that decision, that even if Senator Clinton had reviewed and approved of Ready for Hillary’s mailing and bumper sticker, the Super PAC did not have to say in its disclaimer that the communication was “authorized by” Senator Clinton, for she was not yet a candidate.

This finding—that the rules that govern “candidates” do not yet apply to Senator Clinton or individuals who are “testing the waters”—is more significant when one moves from the question of whether the “authorized by” disclaimer must go on a bumper sticker to the question of whether a discussion with the potential candidate is governed by the FEC’s restrictions on “candidates” coordinating with outside spending groups. It is hard to escape the conclusion from reading the FEC’s decision that until the prospective candidate crosses the statutory line and becomes a “candidate” under the law, the coordination rules do not yet apply to that individual. The FEC’s confirmation of this reading of the plain language of the statute will be seen as very good news by many of the individuals who are currently testing the waters for 2016.

Photo of Robert Lenhard Robert Lenhard

Robert Lenhard is a member of the firm’s Election & Political Law practice group and advises corporations, trade associations, not-for-profit organizations, and high-net-worth individuals on compliance with federal and state campaign finance, lobbying, and government ethics laws.

Mr. Lenhard routinely assists clients in…

Robert Lenhard is a member of the firm’s Election & Political Law practice group and advises corporations, trade associations, not-for-profit organizations, and high-net-worth individuals on compliance with federal and state campaign finance, lobbying, and government ethics laws.

Mr. Lenhard routinely assists clients in establishing and operating federal and state PACs, compliance programs associated with campaign finance and pay-to-play laws; advises advocacy groups and their donors; conducts compliance trainings and audits of federal and state lobbying and political programs; and counsels clients on compliance with congressional gift and travel rules.

Prior to joining the firm in 2008, Mr. Lenhard served as Chairman of the Federal Election Commission (FEC) in 2007 and Vice Chairman of the agency in 2006, during which time the agency handled over 10 major rulemakings, had among its most productive years in enforcement and audit, and adopted several reforms to the enforcement process.  Mr. Lenhard has also led the Presidential Transition Team that reviewed the FEC for the incoming Obama administration in 2008-2009.