The Supreme Court recently granted certiorari in a case to resolve a circuit split that has serious implications for companies who are unsuccessful in their efforts to enforce arbitration provisions in federal district courts. 

In Coinbase, Inc. v. Bielski, No. 22-105, the defendant moved to compel arbitration in two putative class actions.  The motions to compel were denied, and the defendant sought stays while it appealed the denials—which the Federal Arbitration Act gives defendants an automatic right to do.  See 9 U.S.C. § 16.  Both motions to stay were denied, and the Ninth Circuit affirmed both decisions.

Federal appellate courts are divided over whether litigation must be stayed when a defendant appeals a denial of its motion to arbitrate.  The Ninth Circuit was the first to address the issue in 1990 when it held a stay is not required, and the Second and Fifth Circuits followed its lead.  Six other circuits—the Third, Fourth, Seventh, Tenth, Eleventh and D.C. Circuits—have all come to the opposite conclusion, holding that an appeal strips the district court of jurisdiction, and the litigation must be stayed until the appeal is resolved.

The Court’s decision could have a significant impact on companies’ risk assessment when seeking to enforce arbitration provisions.  In circuits that do not automatically stay proceedings while an appeal of an adverse arbitration ruling is pending, companies face greater cost and higher administrative burden when required to proceed in litigation at the district court while simultaneously appealing the denial of their motion to compel arbitration. 

The Court has not yet set a date for argument, but is likely to hear the case in the spring.  We will continue to monitor the proceedings and will provide updates on Inside Class Actions.


Photo of Marianne Spencer Marianne Spencer

Marianne Spencer represents companies in high-stakes litigation in state and federal courts nationwide. Her practice focuses on class actions and complex commercial disputes, with particular depth in defending clients against privacy lawsuits arising from emerging technologies.

Marianne represents clients across the full lifecycle…

Marianne Spencer represents companies in high-stakes litigation in state and federal courts nationwide. Her practice focuses on class actions and complex commercial disputes, with particular depth in defending clients against privacy lawsuits arising from emerging technologies.

Marianne represents clients across the full lifecycle of a dispute—from pre-suit counseling through appeal—and has a strong track record at each phase. Recent successes include defeating class certification in a billion-dollar privacy class action and securing a complete victory for a financial services client facing tens of millions of dollars in potential exposure. She has achieved favorable results for clients in the financial services, technology, pharmaceutical, and sports industries at all stages of litigation, including by securing early dismissals, winning summary judgment, and defeating class certification.

Before joining the firm, Marianne served as a law clerk to the Honorable Steven M. Colloton of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit. She maintains an active pro bono practice focused on civil rights, housing, and immigration.

Photo of Sonya Winner Sonya Winner

A litigator with three decades of experience, Sonya Winner handles high-stakes civil cases for clients in a wide range of industries, including banking, pharmaceuticals and professional sports.  She has handled numerous antitrust and consumer disputes, many of them class actions, in state and…

A litigator with three decades of experience, Sonya Winner handles high-stakes civil cases for clients in a wide range of industries, including banking, pharmaceuticals and professional sports.  She has handled numerous antitrust and consumer disputes, many of them class actions, in state and federal courts across the country.

Sonya’s cases typically involve difficult technical issues and/or complex legal and regulatory schemes. She is regularly able to resolve cases before the trial phase, often through dispositive motions. But when neither summary judgment nor a favorable settlement is an option, she has the confidence of her clients to take the case all the way through trial and on appeal. Her recent successes have included a cutting-edge decision rejecting a “true lender” challenge to National Bank Act preemption in a class action involving interest rates on student loans, as well as the outright dismissal of a putative antitrust claim against the National Football League and its member clubs asserting an unlawful conspiracy to fix cheerleader compensation.

Sonya has been recognized as a leading trial lawyer by publications like Chambers and the Daily Journal. She is chair of the firm’s Class Action Litigation Practice Group.

Photo of Andrew Soukup Andrew Soukup

Andrew Soukup serves as co-chair of the firm’s Class Action Litigation Practice Group. He specializes in representing heavily regulated businesses in class actions, multidistrict litigation, and other high-stakes disputes.

Praised for “big wins in his class action practice,” Andrew has defeated advertising, consumer…

Andrew Soukup serves as co-chair of the firm’s Class Action Litigation Practice Group. He specializes in representing heavily regulated businesses in class actions, multidistrict litigation, and other high-stakes disputes.

Praised for “big wins in his class action practice,” Andrew has defeated advertising, consumer protection, privacy, and product defect and safety claims with exposure ranging from millions to billions of dollars. His “proven record” has earned Andrew recognition as an “attorney you want on your side in a bet-the-company case.” Clients trust Andrew with their most important matters—whether he is leading a defense from the first filing or stepping in midstream with a fresh perspective.

Andrew represents clients in the consumer products, life sciences, financial services, technology, transportation, gaming, and media and communications industries. He has consistently prevailed in litigation in federal and state courts across the country against putative class representatives, government agencies, state attorneys general, and commercial entities.

Drawing on a long history of representing companies subject to extensive federal regulation and oversight, Andrew has a unique ability to help courts understand the complex environment that governs his clients’ businesses. He has earned praise for “understanding the big picture, the strategic vision of the individual case, and how that fits into the broader business strategy of the client.” Clients trust Andrew because of his successful outcomes at every stage of litigation, his responsiveness and attention to their matters, and his deep understanding of their businesses.

Andrew’s recent successes include:

Successfully defending several of the world’s leading companies and brands against class actions accusing them of engaging in deceptive marketing or selling defective products, including claims under state consumer protection and unfair and deceptive acts or practices statutes.
Defeating class certification in a privacy class action against one of the nation’s leading financial institutions.
Defeating industry-wide, multidistrict class-action claims against one of the nation’s leading consumer products companies challenging its marketing of over-the-counter medicine containing allegedly ineffective ingredients—a win that earned Andrew recognition by American Lawyer as a “Litigator of the Week.”
Delivering wins in multiple nationwide class actions for leading financial institutions over fees, disclosures, and other banking practices—including defending several institutions accused of violating the Paycheck Protection Program’s implementing laws, work that contributed to Covington’s recognition as a “Class Action Group of the Year.”
Representing multiple consumer product and life sciences companies against lawsuits seeking economic damages from the sale of products that allegedly caused personal injuries.
Defending several of the world’s most prominent companies against ESG-related claims accusing them of misrepresenting their practices.

Andrew has also achieved favorable outcomes navigating commercial and indemnification disputes between clients and their business partners involving contracts, fraud, and other business torts. He advises on arbitration agreements, has helped numerous clients avoid multidistrict and class-action litigation by enforcing them, and guides companies through mass arbitrations.

A recognized thought leader on class-action issues, Andrew regularly contributes to the firm’s blog, Inside Class Actions. He has been named a Lawyer of the Week by The American Lawyer, included on the Daily Journal’s list of Leading Commercial Litigators (2025), and ranked as a leading litigator by Chambers USA.

Watch: Andrew shares insights on class action litigation, as part of our Navigating Class Actions video series.